Planning & Zoning Board Meeting 07/25/2023 06:30 PM

Planning and Zoning Board Members

District 5 member – Rainey Lane, Chairman
District 1 – David Woods, VChair

District 2 member – Christopher Shenefelt | District 3 member – OPEN
District 4 member – Vinton Squires | District 6 member – Andrew Thompson
District 7 member – Dr. Leonard Hobbs

Welcome to the City of Belle Isle Planning & Zoning meeting. Agendas and all backup material supporting each agenda item are available in the City Clerk's office or on the city's website at www.belleislefl.gov. Any person desiring to appeal a recommended action of the Board should observe the notice regarding appeals below. CAUTION: Untimely filing by any appellant shall result in an automatic denial of the appeal.

1.Call to Order and Confirmation of Quorum

2.Invocation and Pledge to Flag – Board Member Hobbs

3.Approval of Minutes

a.Approval of the P&Z Board Minutes dated June 27, 2023

4.Public Hearings

a.PUBLIC HEARING CASE #2023-06-002 - PURSUANT TO BELLE ISLE CODE SEC. 48-32 (A) (6) (A) AND SEC. 42-64, THE CITY OF BELLE ISLE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD WILL CONSIDER AND TAKE ACTION ON A REQUESTED VARIANCE TO ALLOW A DOCK TO EXTEND GREATER THAN 15 FEET LAKEWARD OF AN EXISTING DOCK WITHIN 300 FEET OF THE PROPOSED LOCATION, SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT MATTHEW LANGBEHN REPRESENTING HOMEOWNER EDWARD HARRISON LOCATED AT 2506 HOMEWOOD DRIVE, BELLE ISLE, FL 32809 ALSO KNOWN AS ORANGE COUNTY TAX PARCEL ID #19-23-30-5888-06-160.

230725 P&Z 2506 Homewood Packet.pdf (1.77 MB)
230725 Staff Report 2506 Homewood Drive.pdf (0.23 MB)

b.PUBLIC HEARING CASE #2023-07-015 - PURSUANT TO BELLE ISLE CODE SEC. 50-73 (A), SEC. 50-102 (A) (4), (5), AND (8) AND SEC. 42-64, THE CITY OF BELLE ISLE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD WILL CONSIDER AND TAKE ACTION ON A REQUESTED VARIANCE TO ALLOW A BUILDING ENCROACHMENT WITHIN 50 FEET OF THE 86.9 CONTOUR LINE OR NORMAL HIGH WATER ELEVATION OF LAKE CONWAY, SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT ALAN LEOW LOCATED AT 2802 ALSACE COURT, BELLE ISLE, FL 32812 ALSO KNOWN AS ORANGE COUNTY TAX PARCEL ID #18-23-30-4385-04-241.

230725 P&Z 2802 Alsace Packet.pdf (0.90 MB)
230725 Staff Report 2802 Alsace Court.pdf (0.23 MB)
230725 P&Z 2802 Alsace Applicant Presentation.pdf (0.82 MB)

c.PUBLIC HEARING CASE #2023-06-008 - PURSUANT TO BELLE ISLE CODE SEC. 48-32 (A) (3), AND (A) (6) (A) AND SEC. 42-64, THE CITY OF BELLE ISLE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD WILL CONSIDER AND TAKE ACTION ON A REQUESTED VARIANCE TO ALLOW A DOCK TO EXCEED THE ALLOWABLE TOTAL AREA FOR A TERMINAL PLATFORM AND TO ALLOW A BOAT DOCK TO EXTEND GREATER THAN 15 FEET LAKEWARD OF AN EXISTING DOCK WITHIN 300 FEET OF THE PROPOSED LOCATION, SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT EMILY WAKELY DELOZIER LOCATED AT 3019 INDIAN DRIVE, BELLE ISLE, FL 32812 ALSO KNOWN AS ORANGE COUNTY TAX PARCEL ID #29-23-30-4389-01-070.

230725 P&Z 3019 Indian Packet.pdf (1.04 MB)
230725 Staff Report 3019 Indian Drive.pdf (0.23 MB)
3019 Indian Drive - July 2023 Variance Hearing - Pictures.pdf (1.35 MB)
3019 Indian Drive - July 2023 Variance Hearing - Petitions.pdf (0.83 MB)

d.PUBLIC HEARING CASE #2023-06-009 - PURSUANT TO BELLE ISLE CODE SEC. 48-32 (A) (3), AND (A) (6) (A) AND SEC. 42-64, THE CITY OF BELLE ISLE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD WILL CONSIDER AND TAKE ACTION ON A REQUESTED VARIANCE TO ALLOW A DOCK TO EXCEED THE ALLOWABLE TOTAL AREA FOR A TERMINAL PLATFORM AND TO ALLOW A BOAT DOCK TO EXTEND GREATER THAN 15 FEET LAKEWARD OF AN EXISTING DOCK WITHIN 300 FEET OF THE PROPOSED LOCATION, SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT JASON LOUCHE REPRESENTING HOMEOWNER ALAN TWICHELL LOCATED AT 3025 INDIAN DRIVE, BELLE ISLE, FL 32812 ALSO KNOWN AS ORANGE COUNTY TAX PARCEL ID #29-23-30-4389-01-080.

230725 P&Z 3025 Indian Packet.pdf (0.86 MB)
Twichell Dock S-1 (1).pdf (0.37 MB)
Twicheldocksurvey.pdf (1.27 MB)
230725 Staff Report 3025 Indian Drive.pdf (0.23 MB)

5.Other Business

a.Discussion and Review on Amending Fences and Walls Ordinance 23-05

ORD 23-05 Fences and Walls Amendments.pdf (0.03 MB)
230725 Fence Ordinance Comments DWW.pdf (0.18 MB)
Pages from Staff Report - Fences Ord 23-05.pdf (0.23 MB)
July P&Z Meeting - ORD 23-05 Fences and Walls Amendments - Staff Comments.pdf (0.15 MB)
190625 P&Z Meeting Minutes Final.pdf (0.39 MB)
FDOT - Reference Material for Ord 23 05 - Pgs 26 & 28.pdf (2.54 MB)

b.Updated Staff Reports Handout to Board

230725 P&Z Updated Staff Report Handouts TO POST FINAL.pdf (3.78 MB)

6.Adjournment

APPEALS: “If a person decides to appeal (Belle Isle’s City Code Section 42-71) any decision made by the Board with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he/she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.”(F. S. 286.0105). A notice of appeal to the City Clerk should be submitted within fifteen (15) days after such recommendation or decision is made “Persons with disabilities needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact the City Clerk‘s Office (407-851-7730) at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.